question Re: addition of nodes doesnt update the slave and regionservers file in Archives of Support Questions (Read Only)

addition of nodes doesnt update the slave and regionservers file

arunpoy — Fri, 30 Sep 2016 21:34:39 GMT

We had a 5 node cluster (2 master and 3 slave nodes). Recently we added 4 more slave nodes. all of this is through ambari. One strange thing we noticed is in all the existing 5 nodes , the /etc/hadoop/conf/slaves and /etc/hbase/conf/regionservers didnt get the entries of the newly added nodes (they have only the 3 slave entries). but the newly added nodes have all the entries for all the 7 hosts. why is it so?

I believe this will cause an issue when we restart. start/stop the hbase service.

but amabri dashboard shows all 7 slaves and we are able to run jobs on all 7 slaves too.

Re: addition of nodes doesnt update the slave and regionservers file

Enis — Sat, 01 Oct 2016 01:28:57 GMT

Ambari does not use these files for managing the HBase service. Those files are only used for custom scripts that come with HBase (bin/start-hbase.sh, etc) which is not needed in an Ambari setup.

Re: addition of nodes doesnt update the slave and regionservers file

cstanca — Sat, 01 Oct 2016 03:35:26 GMT

@ARUN

As @Enis clarified, there will be no impact on your start/stop. If you have custom scripts then you may want fix those files to show all slaves. I have no explanation yet of why the files in the existent slave nodes did not get updated, but you are safe for start/stop.